Thread:Invader Rob II/@comment-29010453-20200623082736/@comment-24549565-20200624054151

OttoLannister550 wrote: Invader Rob II wrote: The simple fact of the matter with regard to the anime is that if it were a 1-on-1 adaptation of the webtoon it would be very difficult to work with. I’ve seen this sadly happen to many wonderful works like the Tokyo Ghoul and Berserk manga. But unlike them, this anime is doing a decent job of extracting the essence of the original webtoon. I’m not one who’s going to shame them for trying to change things up as long as it’s necessary for the format it’s on. It is an adaptation, after all. Well, as one of those people who dislike the anime adaptation, I have my own reasons not to like it. However, I think it is irrelevant to the discussion and I'm just too lazy to explain it.

Anyways, about the Blarouse page, for the most part I agree with Hermes here. The category and history of the character should only be based on the materials or the information from the author himself, not from the anime. I believe the same rule is also applied in other anime wikis. If you want to add an information about the difference between the webcomic and the anime, just write it down on the Notes and Trivia section.

However, despite all of that, I actually agree with you on one thing. I personally do think adding 2 statuses on the character infobox won't do harm and it is actually helpful for the wikia visitors who are interested about the difference between the faith of the character in the webcomic and in the anime but are too lazy to read the entire articles. Keep in mind that the main function of a character infobox is to list some of the general, important information about the character, and that information is surely important, at least to me. We were just sharing thoughts on the anime is all. Of course I had no intention of overriding the source material with the anime, but at the same time I don't feel like this fandom can ignore it. Perhaps we should have a group disscussion regarding the anime adaptation and how its information should be properly implemented while at the same time not intruding on the webtoon's original canon.

Have y’all ever considered creating separate pages for the original webtoon and anime characters and maybe even events, in the likes of Attack on Titan Wiki with the manga and anime? Since there are lot of changes going around in the anime, more so than the pre mentioned wiki, I feel like it could work here. Just my personal idea.