Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-28013738-20170307133051/@comment-16674955-20170309123542

JBennett wrote:

If the cave is completly different place why did SIU said that he will explain more about it later? if it was then just saying their different place would be enough but he said he'll explain more, also he didn't mentioned the outside world so untill he cempletly brings out where Baam and Rachel lived I'm being open to anything. "This place is very important to three of the most important characters of ToG but I won't explain anything about it. Cheers fans, but fuck you I won't explain. Also, more characters, it seems, are linked to it (Enryu and the so-called "God"" of the outside, etc). But still. It's just something and I won't explain sorry."

JBennett wrote: for the language thing, the language that Baam and Rachel speaks must originate from the tower because the pockets they have are able to translate for them and those are made by the residence/ the workshop as far as we know so what they speak must also exsists within the tower. Then let me ask you. How did Headon understand Zahard and his 12 warriors when they arrived on the first floor? How did THEY understand Headon when he talked to them? Because the pockets they are created by the workshop and Macseth, based on a specific language right? The characters who created them, didn't yet. Headon and the other guardians don't use pocket to understand or make themselves understood.

And it leads us to this answer: Baam's and Rachel's language is not, it seems, from the tower. Or, if Rachel was first from the tower and brought outside by say, Arlen, then it would mean that Baam speaks Rachel's language from the tower, which is necessarily translated by the pocket, or even Arlen's language, which is probably Zahard's and the other 12's language.... since Baam was taught to speak by Rachel in the cave.

In any case, it doesn't say that the cave is a part of the tower. Outside of the tower means just that, wherever it is. Outside of my house could be just in from of the door, on the street in front of it, or even on an other continent, and an other planet. All of those locations are outside of my house. But you know, they are not the same "place" outside.

You are probably thinking of the singular, star-filled sky outside that the 13 GW and Urek come from. But the cave not being this place, it seems, doesn't mean that the cave is somewhere in the tower.