Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26207833-20170125174700/@comment-6166034-20170127105350

Lord Asriel Sew wrote: - Rachel's supposed goal is bullshit. SIU said that she's knowledgeable of the outside world. If she's knowledgeable about it, then she must come from the outside world (and so, she used to see the starry sky every night).

If she came from the Tower, she wouldn't possibly know about stars, because only members of Wolkhailsong know about those legends (and she does not belong to Wolkhailsong). All of this to say that legends about the outside world are odd things within the Tower, and they're not common knowledge (let us remind Khun in part 1 at Evankhell's floor when Baam told him about the sky).

So someone forced her to go into the Tower. And that's why Baam took everything from her. Because he took her starry sky from her, to a fake dark night (that are the roofs of the floors in the Tower). SIU said Rachel and Baam know secrets about the outside world. And they definitly come from the outside world. But that doesn't mean they were in places they could see the sky from. Baam was in the cave. We don't know where was Rachel, but she always complains she can't see the sky, and her only way for that is to climb the tower. So it needs to be adressed, but, I don't agree it is bs.

btw: fact check :Khun knew about the stars at the top of the Tower => It is at least known througoout the great families. Note that I already said they come from the outside, just to say that your argument was factualy wrong.

So nothing aligning with your argument there.

Lord Asriel Sew wrote: - Even if she wasn't integrated in FUG's plan to take Baam at the floor of tests, she wasn't that surprised when she met Baam at the train city, she even said to Khun that, to Baam she would be the brightest star ever, before even seeing him alive. Of course she was shocked when they met because she saw how much of a playboy he had become but she seems to know that Baam was alive at the time. Well, maybe someone in FUG told her before, but she is not an official member so... Huh, did you hear that Rachel has the control of the mass information device "Emily" and that even Repellista is using it ? I mean of course she confirmed she's got information from FUG about 135th floor, the 13th month series and princes of red light distrinct. However, it is no wonder she knows about the whereabouts of any "regular" in real time. What is perplexing is that she has predictions abilities, since despite FUG's plans, she invites Khun and Baam to the FoD when the plan is to disolve them all (end of the fight against Hoaqin).

So yeah there're mysteries surrounding Rachel before entering the tower. Of course there're still a lot of questioning concerning what was this "deal" with Headon once inside the tower, and why it included FUG and Headon, and Baam. But that doesn't mean it was linked from the start, and that Rachel is ALWAYS dishonest. She's "omiting" information when she speaks or we see her memory, but that doesn't mean we can't believe in them.