Thread:HermesED/@comment-38940800-20200617070940/@comment-38940800-20200617154622

Wait... doesn't that make Quaetro a failed regular too since he was from the same team as Chang? Also, Wangnan should be a failed regular too then since he was said to have failed the test on the 20th floor multiple times before meeting Baam. Theoritically speaking, doesn't that also mean that we will someday need to put Baam, Khun, and Rak's names on the failed regular list too if they ever fail a floor test in the future, even if just once?

I personally see no point in doing that. Rather than knowing which regulars have ever once failed a test, I think the wikia visitors are more interested about which of the regulars are no longer able to climb the Tower anymore (because of death or getting sent back to the outer tower due to failing the 2nd floor test). The Template:C-Regulars seems to have already reflected the latter assumption (the Failed Regulars being the ones no longer able to climb anymore) while the Template:Regulars follows the former.

So, what do you think? Which assumption should we use? The latter seems to be better in my opinion