Talk:Position/@comment-26484417-20160102202919/@comment-26484417-20160103175120

I'm not sure how YHS's tutelage would affect Viole's classification; YHS is Wave Controller and Viole was originally Wave Controller, I see no discord. As for control over Xia Xia's Lighthouse, we know that wouldn't necessarily make him a Light Bearer, simply consider the case of Hatchuling. As for the Reel Inventory, we have already seen two Light Bearers with Reel Inventories (Prince and Lero-ro), whatever Wangnan's position is, while we yet to see some known Fisherman use Reel Inventory at all... I'm not convinced Viole has one, but I insist that everyone should have it regardless of their position... =P

This again, yes, of course, even the most pathetic 20F Regular can most likely fill in any position on 2F... Same with High Rankers compared to Rankers, etc etc... So the question is "Can High Ranker (~top100) Fisherman perform duties of a Scout equally well as another High Ranker (~top100) Scout?" And if the answer is yes, then there is literally no reason to list any position for High Rankers as it's clearly irrelevant, and if the answer is no, then it should be kept in mind.

Erm, what you say at the beginning of your last paragraph doesn't match its ending. Unless you mean something else there, "jack of all trades" means something else. But if I understand the first part correctly, then you basically agree with the option "B" I previously describe, right?