Talk:White/@comment-27017935-20151229002436/@comment-5693502-20151229020906

The demon that showed itself to Hoaqin gave him something physical (i.e. the spellbook) with which to learn and perform the spell, not to mention it's been referred to as an ancient demon which greatly implies (if not indicates) it has existed long before it came across Hoaqin; it seems like a separate entity to Hoaqin. The demon(?) inside Viole seems to be more of a figment of his imagination or, better yet, a personification of his "power"; it seems like an entity that is part of Viole.

The fake Thorn demon and the Thorn itself, neither have a contract/agreement/deal with Viole. The Thorn itself isn't even sentient to begin with and I'm not even sure we've met the fake Thorn demon yet.