Talk:Position/@comment-26484417-20151128004514/@comment-93.218.235.163-20151129164708

Alright I'm gonna stick to Demo's example to explain it. To make it very obvious let's assume Ha Yurin is a goalkeeper (for the sake of argument not for the sake of similariy to the scout position) but when she plays as a striker (fisherman) she's rivaling the players who usually play there. I doubt Gustang, Eurasia and Tu Perie  are even anywhere close to being in that position. Koon Eduan could probably somewhat fill that role as well, but here comes something that is another point here. Eduan's not being a spear bearer and instead a fisherman would probably significantly weaken the team, even if he is a good fisherman, but I don't think the same has to be said about Ha Yurin. Her aptitude for the fisherman position is so high, that she can almost completely  (I assume there is a point in having a scout afterall so she probably will on average be a lot more effetive in that position, except for some special cases/circumstances or when she felt like it) overcome the downside of not having a scout, or at least not having her as a scout. Maybe that's also true because the scout position can be more ineffective at times, at least probably more so than Eduan's spear bearing.

The thing you say about almost all of them having the potential to fill  in the fisherman position is true, but not under the condition that their team (10 heads and Zahard) remains effective.

To make this a football analogy. Just take any top class defender and put him as a striker in like a local football club and he will destroy everything completely. In contrast putting him in the goalkeeper position or as a defender completely wastes his capabilites to pretty win the game by himself because he can't leverage his insane talent there effectively. So yeeah you would put someone like Gustang as a fisherman if you have only non high rankers or top 100 rankers in your team.