Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-31297098-20170220151321/@comment-26484417-20170222050824

Dimension Creator wrote: I have answered the question as specifically as possible... No, you've answered the question as specifically as you were able; you have already made it clear that this kind of exercise isn't exactly up your alley.

Indeed, there is a vagueness to the scenario, but it's there on purpose. You may have noticed that when you eliminate the vagueness--like in your adjusted scenarios--, it became less of an intellectual exercise and more of an exercise in stating the obvious where the only deviating opinions are likely to come from the radical, the random, and the clueless.

In other words, the vagueness of this scenario isn't something to use as an excuse, it's something for which to account in your reasoning--and doing the former only suggests that you couldn't do the latter.